breed — digital learning experts
breed — digital learning experts

E-learning agency based in Munich. Award-winning since 2014.

The prediction effect in e-learning

Guess first, then compare: how asking questions before an explanation can support learning, and which limits to keep in mind.

Tobias BertenbreiterUpdated: November 19, 2026
Der Prediction Effect: Wie Vorhersagen den Lernerfolg steigern

Experienced teachers and learning designers know the pattern: when learners get to make their own call before they see the solution, even if it’s wrong, they can remember the material better later on. This is known as the prediction effect. It describes the learning benefit of making predictions, especially in situations where the actual information isn’t known yet. For digital instructional design, this principle is highly relevant, because it lets you design learning that is active and cognitively demanding. In this article, we look at why the prediction effect improves learning, which mechanisms from the psychology of learning are at work, and how to put the prediction effect to smart use in e-learning.

What is the prediction effect?

The prediction effect refers to the boost in learning that can occur when learners have to make a guess before new content is presented. Actively anticipating the answer draws attention, activates prior knowledge, and creates a productive level of cognitive tension. What’s especially remarkable: even wrong predictions can improve retention, as long as the correct information follows. The effect overlaps with pretesting and with unsuccessful retrieval attempts (often studied as errorful generation). Unlike retrieving content you have already learned, here the correct answer may still be unknown. What matters instead is how anticipating the answer gets learners’ thinking going.

What predictions set in motion

When an expectation isn’t met, the new information stands out. Attention, activated prior knowledge, and the comparison with your own guess are all plausible explanations for the learning effect. In behavioral experiments by Bein, Plotkin, and Davachi, violating a strong expectation improved memory for individual objects that participants had been shown. That doesn’t mean every mistake is useful, and it isn’t evidence of any particular brain activity while someone works through a web-based training course.

The prediction effect in the psychology of learning

In the psychology of learning, the prediction effect is seen as further evidence that active learning formats work. It pairs easily with concepts like desirable difficulties: a prediction can create exactly that kind of productive challenge. To get a more realistic sense of what they know, learners should compare both their guess and how confident they felt with the explanation that follows. Predictions alone don’t guarantee better metacognition. That makes the effect especially interesting for formative assessment and adaptive learning systems.

Wrong predictions help, under certain conditions

Contrary to the common belief that mistakes get in the way of learning, we see that incorrect predictions can actually be beneficial, provided the correct information follows. How much they help depends, among other things, on how the question relates to the answer that comes later and when it gets resolved. Timely, informative feedback is the deciding factor. Learning systems that ask for predictions therefore need precisely designed feedback to turn errors into something productive.

Putting the prediction effect to work in e-learning

Bringing the prediction effect into digital settings opens the door to a wide range of creative designs. In e-learning modules, for example, you can insert targeted prediction tasks between short pieces of microcontent. In larger web-based training courses (WBTs), multiple-choice questions placed before the information is presented can also work well. With any prediction interaction, the key is to resolve it afterward with a clear explanation. You can also add elaborative prompts: learners answer “Why do you think that?” questions, which builds deeper understanding. Prediction activities can also suit blended learning formats, especially in the phase before the in-person session (flipped classroom).

Best practices for learning designers

To get the full benefit of the prediction effect, keep three design principles in mind:

  • Activate early: Ask for a prediction before you present the information.
  • Resolve and explain: Give the correct information with a clear rationale before a misconception can take hold.
  • Repeat and transfer: Build in follow-up questions that consolidate knowledge and help learners apply it in new contexts.

Looking ahead: predictions at the core of adaptive learning

Prediction-based learning mechanisms are especially relevant for personalized and adaptive learning systems. Learners’ answers can point to the right learning path. But prediction accuracy alone isn’t enough to judge how deep someone’s knowledge goes. And machine learning models are not direct evidence of how humans learn. One particularly promising combination is with schema theory: existing mental structures not only make it easier to recognize new patterns, they also improve the quality of predictions.

Bottom line: the prediction effect as an instructional design tool

The prediction effect proves to be a powerful tool for learning scenarios grounded in instructional psychology. Predictions activate learners, focus their attention, and support long-term retention of new content, especially when mistakes are accepted as part of the learning process and resolved with precise feedback. For learning designers, this means prediction-based formats can spark curiosity and get learners to engage with the material. Whether that works depends on the task, the learners’ prior knowledge, and the feedback.

At breed.design, our learning experts draw on findings like the prediction effect to build digital learning experiences that actively involve learners. With targeted prediction elements, immediate feedback, and context-sensitive design, we foster cognitive engagement and learning that lasts.

Sources and further reading

Tell us what you need. We’ll find the right solution.

Whether it’s a single course, a learning journey or a learning platform like notch.learn, our first call is about understanding what you need and how we can help.