If you work with learning, as we do at breed.design, sooner or later you run into “learning styles.” Some people supposedly learn best through images or video, others through language, and others while they’re moving around. Sounds plausible. But what does the research actually say?
Among other sources, we took a close look at the excellent paper “Learning Styles: Concepts and Evidence” by Pashler et al. (2008). The authors take the popular concept of learning styles apart scientifically, and their verdict is remarkably clear: there is no solid evidence that learning objectively works better when we cater precisely to individual “learning styles.”
What are learning styles, anyway?
Learning styles are the idea that people prefer certain ways of taking in information, and that they learn more successfully when instruction is adapted to those preferences. For example, the “visual learner” supposedly benefits most from diagrams, the “auditory learner” from audio, and so on.
What are the main criticisms?
The paper makes a clear case: many people do report preferences (for example, that they’d rather learn with pictures), but current research shows no benefit when teaching methods are matched to those preferences (what the authors call the meshing hypothesis). Plenty of studies measure preferences, but they don’t show that those preferences translate into objectively better learning outcomes. Studies with a design that could actually test the idea either found no effect or produced contradictory results. So it’s time for an honest assessment: learning styles are not a sound foundation for modern instructional design, however convincing the promise may sound.
Why is this such a big topic?
Despite the lack of evidence, learning styles remain a perennial favorite, among teachers as well as in corporate training and continuing education. There are countless tests (VARK is one of the best known), training courses, and books on the subject. The wish to respond to individual learning needs and sort them into simple categories is understandable, but unfortunately it doesn’t get you where you want to go. Instead of investing time and resources in methods with no proven effect, it makes more sense to focus on broadly effective instructional principles, differentiated tasks, and supportive guidance for all learners.
What’s the better alternative?
That’s why at breed.design, we don’t build on learning styles. We rely on instructional methods backed by research that genuinely support lasting learning:
- Active, exploratory learning: Learners are encouraged to think for themselves, experiment, and solve problems instead of just passively consuming content. Beginners in particular need guidance, examples, and the right kind of support along the way.
- Interactive elements and practice: Quizzes, simulations, reflection tasks, and real-world cases support application. Transfer also takes practice on the job.
- Storytelling and real-world case studies: Stories and real scenarios make learning content tangible and the topic easier to get into.
- Microlearning & clear structure: Learning happens in small, digestible units with clear objectives and an easy-to-follow path. A clear structure and right-sized units make it easier to fit learning into the workday.
- Feedback and social learning: Regular short quizzes, peer interaction, or moderated forums can support learning success when they fit the learning task.
